Using traditional retirement plans

The Pension vs. the 401(k): Exploring Traditional Retirement Plans

There was a time when retirees could count on guaranteed lifetime income from Social Security and an employer pension to fund their golden years. Today’s retirees still enjoy Social Security income, but very few have access to a pension. In 1998 nearly 60 percent of Fortune 500 companies offered a pension. By 2015, fewer than 20 percent offered one.1

As employers have shifted away from the pension, also known as a defined-benefit plan, many have adopted the 401(k). Known as a defined-contribution plan, a 401(k) allows employees to save for their retirement and may create a reduced financial obligation for employers.

As an employee, it may be difficult to know which plan is best for you. You may be in a position where you’re deciding between new jobs, in which one offers a pension and the other a 401(k). Or perhaps you have both a pension and a 401(k) among your retirement assets, and you’re not sure how to use them most efficiently during your retirement years. Below are a few key points to consider as you plan for your retirement:

Pension Plans

Pensions are known as defined-benefit plans because the outcome of the plan, or the benefit, is certain. Your employer pays you a retirement benefit after you exit your career. That benefit amount is determined by a number of factors, including career earnings, length of service, age and more. It’s the employer’s responsibility to fund the plan and pay the promised benefit.

Pension benefits are usually guaranteed for life, but there could be other payment options available. For example, you may be able to take your benefit in a discounted lump sum upfront. Another option could be to take a reduced annual benefit amount but extend the payment over the lives of both you and your spouse.

Obviously, pensions are appealing because they provide guaranteed and predictable income. However, pensions may offer little in the way of growth opportunity. Your income could be flat during retirement, which may be problematic as inflation increases your spending over time.

401(k) Plans

In a defined-contribution plan such as the 401(k), the contribution—rather than the benefit—is certain. The employee determines how much money goes into the plan. The benefit is unknown, because it depends on long-term growth and future contributions. You control how much money goes into the plan, but you can’t control exactly how much comes out in the future.

Your 401(k) contribution is made with pretax dollars, which reduces your taxable income. Your employer may also make a matching contribution. You then invest those funds according to your goals and risk tolerance. All growth is tax-deferred as long as the funds stay in the account. Your withdrawals are then taxed as ordinary income.

One of the challenges with a defined-contribution plan is that the withdrawals aren’t guaranteed. It’s possible that you could drain your assets because of market losses or excessive spending. If you outlive your money, there may be no safety net. Defined contributions may also give you greater upside opportunity, however, and they allow you to control how much money you put toward retirement.

Hybrid Or Alternative Strategies

You can also work with your financial professional to take advantage of aspects of both plans. For example, you could use a 401(k) to accumulate assets during your working years, but then use a different vehicle to generate guaranteed* lifetime income.

For instance, upon retirement you could roll your 401(k) into an IRA, and then use a portion of those funds to purchase an annuity. Many annuities have guaranteed lifetime income features that give you a predictable income stream that will last as long as you live. You get the upside savings potential of a 401(k) with the consistent income you may want in retirement.

Another option is to utilize a properly structured whole life insurance policy to provide income during retirement. When designed specifically for savings purposes, whole life can be a uniquely useful tool that provides a number of benefits during your later years, including tax-free income,** penalty-free withdrawals, and a legacy to your loved ones when you are finished using it.

As many people already have either a 401k or a pension, a combination approach is often needed to meet your retirement income needs.

Ready to plan your retirement strategy? Let’s talk about it! Contact us today to request a free strategy session. We can help you analyze your needs and goals, and then develop a customized retirement plan that works for you.


* Guarantees, including optional benefits, are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuer, and may contain limitations, including surrender charges, which may affect policy values.

** Based on current tax law, assuming policy is correctly structured and maintained. Consult with a qualified insurance professional well-versed in the the Bank On Yourself concept before using this type of strategy.




This information is designed to provide a general overview with regard to the subject matter covered and is not state specific. The authors, publisher and host are not providing legal, accounting or specific advice for your situation. By providing your information, you give consent to be contacted about the possible sale of an insurance or annuity product. This information has been provided by a Licensed Insurance Professional and does not necessarily represent the views of the presenting insurance professional. The statements and opinions expressed are those of the author and are subject to change at any time. All information is believed to be from reliable sources; however, presenting insurance professional makes no representation as to its completeness or accuracy. This material has been prepared for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to provide, and should not be relied upon for, accounting, legal, tax or investment advice.

Leave a Reply